Peer Evaluation Report 
 Peer Evaluator :   Shikha Sharma
 Investigator   :   Kavitha Ashwin
 Lab            :   First Order Lab Part A
 Course         :   Artificial Intelligence 
 Date           :   16th Nov, 2008

Preparation

Overall, i would say Kavitha prepared very well for this lab.Not only did she followed all steps, she also studied online references to work on this lab.

The examples she has come with for explaininh the while explaining the Universal and Existential qualifiers are very good.

However , i think she should have expalined in more details the basic vocab for this lab.

Narrative & Method

Though not any direct questions were asked in this lab, Kaviths has done a good job in answering/explaining the quantifiers. The operator precedence listed in her lab report is essential for overal understanding of quantifier's functionality.

This lab required us to come up with examples of first order logic in relation with Wumpus world. This is missing in Kavitha's report.

Presentation

Kavitha's lab-report is very well presented & organized. I could easily follow the writeup for all the questions asked. It was only in first section that i felt need for more description of basic vocab.

Exploratory skills

I think Kavitha did an excellent job with understainding the first order logic.She came up with good and relevant examples. She also came uup with the logical operator precedence, which was not explictly assigned, but is very critical for overall understanding of first order logic.